Mind map template · Personal

Decision matrix template, as a mind map

Compare options against the same weighted criteria on one map, score each out of ten, and check the winner before you commit.

Shiko is in closed beta: this takes you to the wishlist first.

The template as it opens. Every prompt is a node you answer under or replace.

What's inside

What are we deciding?

  • Criteria and weights
    • Cost (weight 30)
    • Quality (weight 25)
    • Time (weight 25)
    • Risk (weight 20)
  • Option A
    • Cost: score ? / 10
    • Quality: score ? / 10
    • Time: score ? / 10
    • Risk: score ? / 10
    • Weighted total: ?
  • Option B
    • Cost: score ? / 10
    • Quality: score ? / 10
    • Time: score ? / 10
    • Risk: score ? / 10
    • Weighted total: ?
  • Option C
    • Cost: score ? / 10
    • Quality: score ? / 10
    • Time: score ? / 10
    • Risk: score ? / 10
    • Weighted total: ?
  • Verdict
    • Does the winner also feel right?
    • What would have to change for another option to win?
    • Sanity check (a task list)

How to run it with your team

  1. Agree the criteria and weightsThe template starts with cost, quality, time and risk, weighted 30, 25, 25 and 20. Change them to what matters for this decision, before anyone scores.
  2. Score every optionOptions A, B and C each get a score out of ten for every criterion. Score one criterion across all options at a time, so the scale stays the same.
  3. Work out the weighted totalsMultiply each score by its weight and add them up. The option with the highest weighted total wins on paper.
  4. Sanity-check the resultDoes the winner also feel right? What would have to change for another option to win? The task list checks the weights and the scale.

What is a decision matrix?

A decision matrix compares several options against the same list of criteria, gives each option a score on each criterion, and adds the scores up. In a weighted decision matrix each criterion also has a weight, so what matters most counts most. Engineers know a version of it as the Pugh matrix, after Stuart Pugh, who used it to compare designs; teams use the same idea to pick vendors, tools, hires or features.

The method is simple: agree the criteria and their weights first, before anyone has a favourite. Score every option on the same scale, one criterion at a time. Multiply each score by its weight and add them up. The highest total wins on paper, and the numbers show why.

A decision-making matrix is usually a grid, which gets cramped once each score needs a reason. On a mind map each option is a branch with one node per criterion, so you can add the reason under a score, and the Verdict branch makes you check the result before you commit.

When to use it

When you are choosing between three or more options on several criteria: vendors, candidates, tools, office spaces, features to build. A weighted decision matrix makes the trade-offs visible and the decision easier to explain.

It works as a decision grid template too. For a single yes-or-no choice, the pros and cons template is quicker.

Questions

Can my whole team edit it at once?

Yes. Everyone you invite works on the same map live, and you see who is typing where.

How do I work out a weighted total?

Multiply each score by its weight, then add the results. With the template’s weights, an option scoring 8 on cost, 6 on quality, 7 on time and 9 on risk gets 8 × 30 + 6 × 25 + 7 × 25 + 9 × 20 = 745 out of 1000.

Does it calculate the totals for me?

No. The map holds the scores and weights; you add up the weighted totals and write them in.

Can I add options or criteria?

Yes. Copy an option branch, or add a criterion to each; the template becomes your own map.