Mind map template · Analysis

Pros and cons template, as a mind map

Weigh a decision on one map: the pros, the cons, what would soften them, and a verdict with a next step, so the list ends in a choice.

Shiko is in closed beta: this takes you to the wishlist first.

The template as it opens. Every prompt is a node you answer under or replace.

What's inside

Should we…?

  • Pros ✓
    • A benefit we get right away
    • A benefit that grows over time
    • A risk we avoid by choosing this
    • What we gain compared with the alternative
  • Cons ✗
    • The cost in money, time or effort
    • What could go wrong
    • What we give up by choosing this
    • Something we might regret later
  • How to soften the cons
    • What would reduce the cost or the risk?
  • Verdict
    • Do the pros outweigh the cons?
    • Next step (a task list)

How to run it with your team

  1. Write the decision as a questionReplace "Should we…?" with the choice in front of you: "Should we move the launch to March?"
  2. List the prosFour prompts get you past the obvious: a benefit you get right away, one that grows over time, a risk you avoid, and what you gain over the alternative.
  3. List the cons, then soften themThe cost, what could go wrong, what you give up and what you might regret. Then ask what would reduce each cost or risk: a con you can fix is no reason to say no.
  4. Give a verdictDo the pros outweigh the cons? The Next step task list asks who tells the others and when you review how it went.

What is a pros and cons list?

A pros and cons list puts the reasons for a choice on one side and the reasons against it on the other, so you can see them together instead of going round in circles. It is one of the oldest decision tools there is: in 1772 Benjamin Franklin wrote to a friend that he split a sheet in two, wrote pros on one side and cons on the other over a few days, then crossed out reasons of equal weight until he could see which side was left.

A good list of pros and cons is about one decision, written as a yes-or-no question. Each point is specific ("costs two weeks of work", not "takes time"), and both sides get the same effort. Some points weigh more than others, so counting them is not enough: three small pros can lose to one big con.

A mind map adds what a two-column table lacks: room under each point for the detail behind it, a branch for ways to soften the cons, and a verdict that turns pros vs cons into a decision and a next step.

When to use it

For a yes-or-no decision with one option on the table: take the job, switch tools, hire now or later. A pro and con list is quick, and with a pro con template on a map the whole team can add to it at once.

When you are choosing between three or more options, use the decision matrix template instead: it scores every option against the same weighted criteria.

Questions

Can my whole team edit it at once?

Yes. Everyone you invite works on the same map live, and you see who is typing where.

Is a mind map better than a two-column pro con list?

It holds the same two columns, plus room under each point for detail and a branch for softening the cons, which a table has no place for.

How to make a pros and cons list?

Write the decision as a question, then list the pros and the cons, at least three of each. Mark the points that matter most, ask how each con could be reduced, and decide whether the pros outweigh what is left. End with a next step and a date to check how it went, or the list never turns into a decision.

Can I change the prompts?

Yes. The template becomes your own map: rename, add or delete any branch or prompt.